Geneva Academy>
24 April 2024
As part of their core course on International Humanitarian Law (IHL), given by Professor Marco Sassòli, 20 students of our LLM in IHL and Human Rights took part in pleadings on 20 April on the current armed conflict in and around Gaza and the West Bank. The students were randomly assigned a side to represent – either Israel or Palestine – and were obliged to argue that their side had respected IHL while the adverse side had violated it. The choice to undertake this exercise on a current, ongoing armed conflict, was a decision voted by the students, and is the first time this has happened in this class.
Geneva Academy
Geneva Academy
Geneva Academy
In front of a jury composed of Professor Sassòli and teaching assistant Revaz Tkemaladze, teams of two students pleaded on:
These issues were selected to offer each side possible legal arguments, where other practices could not have been justified under international humanitarian law by the party responsible.
‘This exercise challenges the students to not only think of the creative ways in which they can persuasively defend their clients, identifying the facts they need to make their legal arguments, but to also practice the art of advocacy. Presenting arguments with vigor and strength requires a combination of different skills. It also presents an opportunity to practice IHL as professionals and trains them in delivering convincing submissions before domestic and international courts as international lawyers’, noted Revaz Tkemaladze.
Professor Sassòli reflected, ‘I admired the quality of most of the arguments, but above all the fact that the students accepted to take part in this exercise in the current tense atmosphere, calmly but professionally arguing on behalf of a party to the conflict for which they do not necessarily have sympathy and which they perhaps consider responsible for the current situation. These students understood something what is rarely understood in relation to the current war: even those fighting for the best cause must respect international humanitarian law.’
Revaz Tkemaladze continued, ‘Despite the intensity of the LLM program and multitude of other assignments going on in parallel, the students showed their full dedication to this activity and excelled in their pleading presentations. The complexity of this pleading cannot be underestimated as it required understanding of both historical events and evolving situation on the ground, as well as tackling complex legal questions surrounding siege and urban warfare or interplay between the law of occupation and the law governing the conduct of hostilities. To accomplish this, they researched through the plethora of legal and factual material, such as reports, commentaries, articles, blog posts, findings of international organizations, domestic and international court decisions and parties’ actual pleadings. The submissions were well-researched and nuanced, exceeding our expectations.’
Interested LLM students who were not pleading had the possibility to watch their peers and improve their understanding of the legal issues surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
In mid May, the other half of the class will plead in a similar way in favor of Russia or Georgia concerning the armed conflict in Georgia in 2008.
Geneva Academy
Geneva Academy
Geneva Academy
In the 2023-24 academic year students from our two Geneva based Masters Programmes embarked on study trips to Georgia and Morocco.
Our podcast In and Around War(s) returns for a third season.
OUP
In this book launch our Swiss IHL Chair, Professor Marco Roscini, will discuss the main findings of his new book on the principle of non-intervention with leading experts.
UN Photo
This online short course focuses on the role of public international law in international relations and on international legal persons.
ICRC
This online short course provides an overview of the content and evolution of the rules governing the use of unilateral force in international law, including military intervention on humanitarian grounds and the fight against international terrorism. It focuses on the practice of states and international organizations.
UNAMID
This project will develop guidance to inform security, human rights and environmental debates on the linkages between environmental rights and conflict, and how their better management can serve as a tool in conflict prevention, resilience and early warning.
Shutterstock
This project will explore humanitarian consequences and protection needs caused by the digitalization of armed conflicts and the extent to which these needs are addressed by international law, especially international humanitarian law.