Our Third-Party Intervention in Ukraine and the Netherland v. Russia

30 May 2023

In Ukraine and the Netherlands v. Russia, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) will have the opportunity to clarify and develop several topical points concerning the interpretation and application of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) in situations of international armed conflict. The magnitude of the events from which the case stems is matched by the importance of the legal determinations that the Court is called upon to make.

The Geneva Academy has been granted leave by the ECtHR to intervene as a third party in this case – along with 26 governments – and submitted its third-party intervention on 28 April 2023.

Reflecting the salience of this case, the intervention focuses on three main subjects: (1) the extraterritorial application of the ECHR in an international armed conflict; (2) the relationship between the ECHR and international legal norms governing recourse to armed force between states (ius ad bellum); (3) the interplay between the ECHR and international humanitarian law (IHL).

Providing Legal Inputs to Help the Court Decide the Case

When preparing our third-party intervention, the chief concern was to provide legal inputs and elements that could help the Court decide the case.

‘Impartiality, objectivity and the interests of the proper administration of justice have been our guiding principles’ explains Professor Gloria Gaggioli, Director of the Geneva Academy.

‘The range of legal issues raised by the allegations is extraordinarily varied and complex. It brings into the picture the recent case law of the Court, but also doctrinal developments and the practice of other human rights bodies. We strived, in our submission, to reflect all these different aspects, with particular attention to the positions and the reflections that the Geneva Academy’s faculty and researchers have elaborated during the years’ underlines Dr Francesco Romani, Research Fellow at the Geneva Academy and in charge of our IHL-Expert Pool.

Next Steps

The third-party intervention has been forwarded to the parties to the case, who have been invited to include any observations which they may wish to make in reply in their written memorials which are due by 2nd October 2023.

‘We are of course at the disposal of the Court to provide additional clarifications or oral explanations regarding our submission’ says Professor Gaggioli.

An Illustrative Example of the IHL-Expert Pool Impact

This third-party intervention represents an additional, extremely important way in which the IHL Expert-Pool (IHL-EP) operates.

‘Over the years, the ECtHR has been increasingly called upon to adjudicate on claims (arising from both inter-state cases and individual applications) alleging violation of human rights in situations of armed conflict. Through our IHL-EP, we can offer targeted IHL advice that the Court could integrate in its decisions, so as to maximize their relevance, coherence and acceptability’ explains Dr Erica Harper, Head of Research and Policy Studies at the Geneva Academy.

‘We hope that this will create positive dynamics, resulting in increased protection for victims of human rights violations as well as in stronger incentives for compliance with IHL norms’ she adds.

MORE ON THIS THEMATIC AREA

Expert roundtable on digital human rights tracking tools and databases News

Digital Human Rights Tracking Tools and Databases: Pioneering Discussions at the Expert Roundtable

22 September 2023

More than 30 DHRTTD developers and users representing different permanent missions, national ministries, international and regional organizations, national human rights institutions, civil society organizations and academia delved into the transformation digital tools bring to the human rights landscape.

Read more

Dr Erica Harper at the UN Human Rights Council Advisory Committee News

Our Expert Inputs UN Discussion on the Regulation of Emerging Military Technologies

11 August 2023

Dr Harper shed light on military technologies’ potential impact on human rights and addressed the risks associated with the cross-application of these technologies and the related need for regulation.

Read more

Closeup of the Meta sign at the entrance to the Meta Platforms headquarters in Menlo Park, California. Event

A New Human Rights Tribunal in Town? The Oversight Board and the Future of Online Freedom of Expression

18 October 2023, 18:00-19:30

This Human Rights Conversation will explore the extent to which an independent mechanism such as the Meta Oversight Board is akin to a human rights tribunal and the risks that could be linked to delegating such powers to a private authority.

Read more

Ruined houses of Borodianka, Ukraine Event

2023 Current Issues in Armed Conflict Conference

26 October 2023

This annual conference co-organized with the University of Essex provides a space for experts and practitioners, diplomats, academics, young scholars and civil society representatives to discuss contemporary legal issues in armed conflict.

Read more

An aerial view of camps for internally displaced persons (IDPs), which have appeared following latest attacks by M23 rebels and other armed groups in the North Kivu region of the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). Short Course

International Refugee Law

28 February - 3 April 2024

This online short course analyses the main international and regional norms governing the international protection of refugees. It notably examines the sources of international refugee law, including the 1951 Geneva Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees, and their interaction with human rights law and international humanitarian law.

Read more

Syria,  Aleppo, great Umayyad mosque. Destructions. Short Course

The Interplay between International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights

29 February - 15 March 2024

This online short course focuses on the specific issues that arise in times of armed conflict regarding the respect, protection and fulfilment of human rights. It addresses key issues like the applicability of human rights in times of armed conflict; the possibilities of restricting human rights under systems of limitations and derogations; and the extraterritorial application of human rights law.

Read more

Panel Discussion: Project

Treaty Body Members’ Platform

Started in January 2014

The Treaty Body Members’ Platform connects experts in UN treaty bodies with each other as well as with Geneva-based practitioners, academics and diplomats to share expertise, exchange views on topical questions and develop synergies.

Read more

First annual conference of the Geneva Human Rights Platform Project

The Annual Conference of the Geneva Human Rights Platform

Started in June 2019

Read more

Cover page of the Working Paper Publication

Exploring Counterterrorism Effectiveness and Human Rights Law

published on September 2023

Gloria Gaggioli, Michael Moncrieff , Ilya Sobol

Read more