Geneva Academy Professor presents to OSCE Member States Report on Violations of IHL in the Armed Conflict in Ukraine

Professor Marco Sassòli has been appointed on 15 March as one of three experts on a mission to investigate violations of international humanitarian law (IHL) and international human rights law (IHRL) in Ukraine for the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE).

This mission was conducted under the Moscow Mechanism, at the request of Ukraine and following the suggestion of 45 participating States. The report of the three experts was to be submitted within three weeks of the establishment of the mission, which was possible despite the scale of the situation, which continues to evolve. However, the mission was no longer able to analyse the allegations of horrific massacres that had emerged since 1 April 2022.

Violations of IHL

The report was presented on 13 April by the three experts to the OSCE Permanent Council.

Professor Sassòli was in charge of the IHL part of the report. In that part, the mission found that, during the period under consideration, violations of IHL occurred both on the Ukrainian as well as on Russian sides. It also found that both sides have also, in many instances, respected IHL. The Russian violations are, however, more serious in nature and scale.

Regarding violations of IHL, the mission found clear patterns of violations by the Russian forces on many of the issues investigated. This concerns in particular their conduct of hostilities.

‘It is not conceivable that so many civilians would have been killed and injured and so many civilian objects, including houses, hospitals, cultural property, schools, multi-story residential buildings, administrative buildings, penitentiary institutions, police stations, water stations and electricity systems would have been damaged or destroyed if Russia had respected its IHL obligations in terms of distinction, proportionality and precautions in conducting hostilities in Ukraine’ underlines Professor Sassòli.

‘The conduct of the siege of Mariupol is an extreme example. Much of the conduct of Russian forces in parts of Ukraine it occupied before and after 24 February 2022, including through its proxies, the self-proclaimed ‘republics’ of Donetsk and Luhansk, equally violates IHL of military occupation’ he adds.

Some violations and problems were also identified regarding the practices of Ukraine.

‘The mission is in particular concerned about the treatment of prisoners of war, originally considered criminals, and treated in ways that are incompatible with Geneva Convention III. However, allegations that Ukraine and not Russia had caused some of the death, injury or destructions attributed to Russia by the media, Ukrainian authorities and NGOs could not be confirmed’ explains Professor Sassòli.

‘The mission is also astonished about the small number of prisoners of war acknowledged by both parties and regrets that they do not yet benefit from ICRC visits prescribed by Geneva Convention III’ he adds.

Crucial Support from UNIGE Doctoral Student and Geneva Academy Alumni

Professor Sassòli could not have written his part in such a short time without the decisive help of his doctoral student at the University of Geneva, Ms Eugénie Duss, and of two Geneva Academy alumni who do not wish to be identified, one of whom, standing in midst of professional life, having offered spontaneously his pro bono assistance for more than one week, several years after having graduated at the Geneva Academy.

MORE ON THIS THEMATIC AREA

Durkhanay Ijaz at her desk News

Executive Master in International Law in Armed Conflict: What Participants Say Durkhanay Ijaz

23 May 2022

Durkhanay Ijaz is a Legal Advisor at the International Committee of the Red Cross in Pakistan and is following our Executive Master in International Law in Armed Conflict online.

Read more

Portrait of Said Condo Ndoli News

Executive Master in International Law in Armed Conflict: What Alumni Say

10 June 2022

Said Condo Ndoli is the Head of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) sub-delegation in Timbuktu, Mali and graduated from our Executive Master in International Law in Armed Conflict in 2021.

Read more

A wide view of the UN Security Council Short Course

Sanctions in Public International Law

11 January - 21 February 2023

This online short course provides an introduction to the regime of sanctions under international law and their effectiveness in addressing contemporary forms of conflict. It addresses the questions related to state responsibility, the pacific settlement of international disputes and the role of the International Court of Justice.

Read more

The International Court of Justice in session Short Course

Sources of Public International Law

26 October - 13 December 2022

This online short course dwells on the means of international law-making (treaties, customary international law, unilateral acts, general principles of law etc.). In other words, the course looks at the sources from which public international law rules stem and at the entities that are empowered with the capacity of law-making in the international legal order.

Read more

Mine Project

Business, Human Rights and Conflict-Affected Regions

Started in July 2021

This project aims to further identify and clarify policies and practices for States and business, including public and private investors, across the full ‘conflict cycle’ and the ‘Protect, Respect and Remedy’ pillars of the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights.

Read more

A session of the UN Human Rights Committtee at Palais Wilson Project

Implementing International Humanitarian Law Through Human Rights Mechanisms

Completed in April 2019

This project examined how IHL could be more systematically, appropriately and correctly dealt with by the human rights mechanisms emanating from the UN Charter, as well as from universal and regional treaties.

Read more

Cover of the Publication Publication

The Future Digital Battlefield and Challenges for Humanitarian Protection: A Primer

published on April 2022

Henning Lahmann

Read more